mood:
sad
music: Waiting on the World to Change – John Mayer
“It is indeed a bitter pill to swallow. But we cannot allow distorted facts and shallow tactics–the foundation on which our opponents built their campaigns–to break our spirits. We are on the right side of history–and we will continue this journey.”
Make no mistake. We are bowed, but not discouraged. We are sad, but not disheartened. We grieve, but not as those who are without hope.”
- Joe Solmonese, Human Rights Campaign President
I just came home from watching Milk, a biopic on Harvey Milk, the first openly gay man to be elected to public office in the U.S. (as a member of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors) He was tragically assassinated after ten months in office, by Dan White, another city supervisor. White also assassinated the mayor of San Francisco at the time, George Moscone. When Milk died, about 30,000 people marched in San Francisco for him. It was a fantastic movie–moving, inspiring, heartbreaking. I bawled my eyes out at the theater and watched the credits roll, thinking. When I went to my car to drive home, I sat in the backseat for a while, crying, before I got myself together and propped my No on 8 sign nicely on the back of my car (it had fallen flat last week and I had been too lazy to prop it up slanted properly).
I drove by the intersection where I’d protested against California’s Proposition 8 back in October, and I thought about the fight that we’re still fighting. I thought about all the students organizing a protest on Facebook, and I thought about how I got to participate in it and scream my lungs out, fighting for my rights. Then, I thought about the absolutely JoinTheImpact rally at City Hall on November 15th, protesting on the street as over a million people protested all over the nation. Hundreds stood in front of my city hall alone.
I thought about how when I was telling Kelly about the protests and about how proud and happy I had been to do my part in the fight for civil rights, Erin said to me, “I don’t get why people are still campaigning for this… It’s doesn’t make any sense…” and how when I told her about the three court cases and how the fight is still going on, she said “Wow, are you serious? I’m sorry, but that’s just ridiculous. The people have voted–isn’t this the second time something like this has come up and been voted down by the majority anyway?”
And mostly, I thought about how I said quietly but firmly, my heart heavy and deeply saddened by her obvious disapproval–”Would you stop fighting for your personal rights? I don’t know about you, but I would much rather the courts make a decision about the constitutionality of Prop 8 than have people prejudiced against me decide who I can or cannot marry.”
It was the first time I’ve really stood up to Erin. I still think about it all the time, and it saddens me that she and I could be so close, but it’s…very difficult for me to swallow our ideological differences. I don’t necessarily let it come between us; I still love her dearly and treasure her as a friend. But sometimes, it hurts like hell, knowing that she… She proclaims to be my friend, but when it comes down to something like giving me the right to marry who I want, regardless of their gender, she is not swayed from her position.
Just like it hurt like hell when, back in sophomore year, Maggie and I argued about gay rights, and I cried the entire day away.
I don’t understand how you can… How you can oppose a movement that directly impacts the rights of two of your close friends. Not just one, but two. And not just any friends, but… God, I don’t know. I’m a good person. I know I am. I’m a law-abiding citizen. I’ve never smoked, never done any drugs, and the only alcohol I’ve ever tasted is two glasses of champagne at a New Year’s party this past January. I never drive above the speed limit, and I don’t shoplift or trespass private property. I’ve never cheated on a test, I’ve never ditched class on purpose. I study harder than anyone I know and work an honest job at my family’s store. I love genuinely and certainly am not experimenting: I’ve only been involved with two people in the eighteen years of my life, with one girl and one guy–and gender has been irrelevant in both cases. I am not a sexual deviant and definitely never sleep around; instead, I fall head over heels in love (or at least infatuation) with people. I am extremely generous and often give myself over to perpetuate the happiness of the people around me. I always try to be there for my friends. I don’t cause conflicts, I don’t argue with people, I try my best to be super polite and courteous. And my friends know all of this better than anyone! But… It’s still not enough.
Why?
Do I not mean enough to you?
Am I not enough to prove that homosexuality is not a choice, a disease, or a freakazoid mutation?
I’m a lipstick bisexual, for god’s sake. I like cute heels and sexy jewelry and makeup. I’m a lipstick bisexual, and not even the slutty kind. I’ve only kissed one girl in my life–and one guy, for that matter! You would never even suspect my sexuality, probably even if you saw me wearing my ten No on 8 pins. And yet still…
I want to know what it is. What is it that makes me different from you? No… What is it that makes me not deserve the same rights as you do? You know me–is there really something about me that just dictates that I’m really so different from you?
These questions bother me relentlessly, and they have since middle school.
I just don’t understand.
And frankly, it tears me apart.
This wall you put between me and you.
More walls… It’s always the walls, isn’t it?
P.S. BTW, Milk got Top Box Office even though its restricted release on 11/26 only showed in 36 theaters ($1.3 mill!), and it has a whopping 94% rating on RottenTomatoes! You should really see it; it’s a magnificent history lesson/political documentary/romance story.


